Skip to Content

The Bay Area’s best music critics pick the best songs of 2025

A selection of hits from a fabulous group of local writers and editors

From left to right, Underscores, Dijon, Debby Friday, P-Lo. Photo: Courtesy of Artist

Last year, I asked a few of the Bay Area’s finest culture writers to share their five favorite songs of the year with us. I like to think of it like Pazz & Jop on a hyper-local scale; a snapshot of the shared musical tastes of people who live and work here. So, we’re bringing it back this year, with a lot of last year’s contributors and a couple of new faces.  

It’s always a fun collection of tracks: These 35 songs cross musical styles and regional scenes; some are hugely zeitgeist-y, and others are excavated gems far beyond any algorithm or hype machine. Most contributors featured at least one artist with Bay Area ties. I also threw in a handful of songs I kept on constant repeat. 

My hope is that this list feels like friends of friends choosing songs for you. They might delight or, better yet, vex you, but we can guarantee that a human loves each and every song on this list enough to put it on the internet. I hope you take some time in the dog days of 2025 to dig in and enjoy.

You can stream the playlist on Spotify and Apple Music. We’ll also link to individual songs for purchase on Bandcamp, if available.

Timothy Karoff, culture reporter at SFGATE

John-Paul Shiver, contributor at 48 Hills and Treble

Gabe Meline, senior editor at KQED Arts & Culture

Leah Isobel, contributor at 48 Hills and The Singles Jukebox

Alan Chazaro, co-founder at COYOTE Media Collective

Alex Ramos, editor at Sunstroke Press and contributor at Pitchfork

  • Hayley Williams — “Good Ol' Days”
  • Hearts2Hearts — “STYLE”
  • Kehlani — “Folded”
  • NMIXX — “KNOW ABOUT ME”
  • PinkPantheress — “Stateside”

Joshua Bote, associate editor, Gazetteer SF 

Thanks for reading! If you liked this article, share it with someone. That’s the best way for new readers to discover Gazetteer SF.

More Stories

Rest in pixels, Salon

This week: Flooding, IPOs, and a public urinal

November 20, 2026

The Dolores Park pissoir turns 10

Political wiz Scott Wiener’s open-air urinal is a perfect metaphor for San Francisco

November 20, 2026

Faced with global extinction, anti-AI protestors ask Anthropic to ‘please stop’

More than 100 people rallied in SoMa to demand the $1.5 trillion company ban self-improving AI on the day of its initial public offering. Four protesters were arrested

November 19, 2026

There’s no free lunch

AI leaders say that the age of limitless abundance is nearly upon us, but they’ve forgotten that in the end, someone always has to pay

November 18, 2026

Businesses across SF forced to close amid widespread flooding

“This year, I think all bets are off. We’re expecting a bad season.”

November 18, 2026